Inspired by these quotes, I decided to start a thread.
So rank your top 10. I'll wait until Super Bowl Sunday to compile the tally, with 10 points for a 1st place vote, 9 for 2nd, and so on down to 1 point for #10.
Use any criteria you want. Feel free to add justifications if you like. Just be sure to rank them 1-10. But if you want to talk about all the guys who coached before most of us were born, start your own thread.
I'll start:
This was the last place we were discussing all time NFL coaches that I can remember. I think we agree on BB @1 so let me ask this: What does Andy Reid need to do to get to second place? Let’s say he wins this year. That’s 2 SBs and he has been to 4 conference Championships in a row with 2 different teams.
That’s not enough to get to second but that puts him in some rare air.
I first thought we could do the SOSH-tradition of making this a tread with nominations that can then turn into a poll of sorts. But since we aren't just trying to name #1 or even #2 after a certain hoodie-wearing dude in Foxboro, maybe we do this as a ranked thing in this thread, instead.What’s the top ten? Is he already better than Shula? Lombardi? Noll? He’s only won one SB but been to three.. it would seem that winning two puts him onto the next tier with a number of other greats that won two. Noll won four. How does his winning percentage stack up?
So rank your top 10. I'll wait until Super Bowl Sunday to compile the tally, with 10 points for a 1st place vote, 9 for 2nd, and so on down to 1 point for #10.
Use any criteria you want. Feel free to add justifications if you like. Just be sure to rank them 1-10. But if you want to talk about all the guys who coached before most of us were born, start your own thread.
I'll start:
- Belichick
- Lombardi
- Noll
- Shula
- Walsh
- Madden
- Landry
- Gibbs
- Parcells
- Reid